Ethicist Defends Surrogacy As Justifiable Option

An advice column responds to a reader in her 30s with a health condition that complicates pregnancy, evaluating whether paid surrogacy is ethically permissible. The columnist contrasts commercial versus altruistic and domestic versus international surrogacy, flags exploitation risks in countries like Georgia and Ukraine, and argues that psychological or mental-health reasons can count as medical indications requiring informed-consent safeguards.
Key Points
- 1Distinguishes commercial, altruistic, domestic, and international surrogacy; US contexts show lower exploitation risk
- 2Highlights epistemic injustice where patients' mental-health pregnancy concerns are dismissed as non-medical
- 3Advises practitioners to treat psychological indications seriously and ensure informed consent and ethical screening
Scoring Rationale
Balanced ethical analysis provides practical guidance, but limited novelty and low relevance to data-science professionals.
Sources
Public references used for this report.
Practice with real Health & Insurance data
90 SQL & Python problems · 15 industry datasets
250 free problems · No credit card
See all Health & Insurance problems
